Reviews & Comments
Apple
Home
Reviewed by Peter Neall

I very much looked forward to getting and reading 'The Apple and the Thorn' the first attempt at a novel written by Emma Restall Orr, one of the foremost Druid teachers in the UK whose teaching I have long admired and Walter William Melnyk, a former minister in the Episcopal church in the USA with a long and deep interest in Druidry and its influence on Christianity.

So when I did get it I dived in eagerly. I was expecting a story about the deep history of Britain, its myths and characters who exerted a profound influence on our later collective psyche. I got those in a story rich in myth, characterisation and history. The story is told by each of the two main characters in their own distinctive voice.

Joseph of Arimethea, known as Eosaidh in the book, comes to England in his job as a trader and traveller and meets Vivian, the High Priestess of the Goddess at Avalon. Their meeting has a profound effect on them both and this story begins when Joseph, ready to cease from his travelling, comes to end his life in the West Country. Here he encounters Vivian again and their story of love and honour unfolds in the context of the ending of one world and the dawn of another as the Romans invade and change England forever.

Like all good stories once begun I could not put it down , it drew me in and I wanted to know what happened. But more than that it surprised and even shocked me. Even in the compulsion of wanting to know what happened I had to pause, to wait as if for breath and let the story happen to me before continuing.

Vivian describes the land, my land as only a priestess can and I am drawn to see and feel things locked deep in my memory that I had forgotten I remembered. Mud between the toes, darkness, real darkness of the sky at night and the sounds and touch of the marsh, of water and of the land. It is not the description of the land it is the gift of the land.

There is more - as she shows Eosaidh the difference between men and women my eyes are opened and my breath hurts. I am given a secret which has been before me all my life that until now I have never seen so clearly.

Eosaidh's response is authentic and honourable in a new deeper sense of the word that goes beyond our normal usage. I hear his voice, feel the turbulence in his heart, and the deep longings of his soul as if they were mine.

The book gives me more than a wonderful story. Today I looked at the land and the people I live with differently. That is a gift worth reading for.

The Story line and it's journey is so enjoyable and easily read as a piece of 'fiction' and I'm guessing there will be many who will pick this up as a 'story book' with no experience of the 'Craft Paths' and feel underlying 'truths' in the story.

I finished 'Apple and Thorn ' amidst all the chaos of my three children playing around my feet and found tears running down my face.

I honestly don't know how to write a review of this book. For me, both of your writing in this book hits very close to home and contains much I identify with (obviously heavily coloured with my own experiences) :

Bobcat : in your writing I see much of what you tried to teach me and that I grokked but couldn't quite 'see' in words that I could understand, and this book has helped place those intuitions in words.

Oakwyse: I recognised the confusion felt by 'Eos' and his attempts to understand the teachings and concepts - it is a 'gentle joke' with BC and her Apprentices that there is a lot of the Church of England Choir boy I was once was, still in me. 'Eos' journey to understand is wonderfully written and 'experienced'.

The two of you have crafted a beautiful book that resonates so wonderfully within me; all though it may sound silly, I want to say thank you both for creating it.

Wayne Danewood

The Apple and the Thorn, A Timeless Tale for the Ages
Reviewed by Pat Mead

Is it a novel? Is it a theological treatise? Is it myth reworked? Well… yes, yes and yes. It’s a bumblebee too. You know – theoretically the bee’s body is too heavy for its wings, making it unable to fly. However, the bee doesn’t know it’s aerodynamically unsound, and it manages to fly very nicely, thank you. The weight of theology and philosophy in The Apple and the Thorn ought to keep it mired on the ground, but somehow it manages to fly right up there alongside the bumblebee. (And produces some fine honey too.)

The two main characters in the story are Joseph of Arimathea (called Eosaidh in the book), and Vivian, the Lady of the Lake. The narration moves from one to the other and begins as Eosaidh arrives in Avalon, fifteen years after his great-nephew was crucified in Jerusalem. Eosaidh settles on what is now Wearyall Hill, and meets his old friend Vivian once more. They seek to understand each other’s spirituality, exploring their very different beliefs about the divine, about male and female, light and dark, the outer and the inner worlds, and the importance of the land itself. Often they misunderstand each other, but there is always liking and respect between them, and before long they have become lovers.

The peaceful idyll is shattered with the arrival of strangers who lay claim to twelve hides of Avalon’s sacred land. They are converts to the new Christian cult, and they see the Lady and her people as sorceresses and demons. Hot on their heels are the pragmatic Romans who seek only to quell rebellion and seize the wealth and resources of the land. Eosaidh’s loyalties are torn in many directions and the love that he and Vivian share is tested to the limit.

Reading The Apple and the Thorn was a delightful experience for me. As I neared the end, I read ever more slowly, wanting to postpone for as long as possible the moment of our separation. I knew how it would end, but the tears are still on my cheeks as I write.

Pat Mead
Touchstone
The Order of Bards, Ovates, and Druids

Review by Caillu Brigana
in La Rouelle
www.druides.org

Ecriture à 4 mains pour ce roman, où Emma Restall Orr est rejointe par Bill Melnyk. J’ai adoré cette double écriture, cette alternance, ou comment une même scène peut être racontée par les deux personnages… Une belle vision de la fin d’Avalon, de la rencontre du christianisme et du paganisme, ou comment la petite histoire se tisse à la grande.

This novel is written in four hands, where Emma Restall Orr is joined by Bill Melnyk. I loved this double writing, this alternation, and how the same scene can be described by both characters. A beautiful vision of the end of Avalon, the meeting of Christianity and Paganism, and how a small story (of two people) weaves in with the big history..
5.0 out of 5 stars A profoundly beautiful book, 3 Feb 2010
By Red Fox (Britain)

reviews This is no ordinary re-telling of the Avalonian current. In fact it is not a re-telling at all, it is a telling. This book feels like it has been midwifed by the authors as the Land struggles to make Herself heard in the present age. It is a telling that is rooted deep in the land of Britain and Her mythic heart of Affalon. It feels as if the book has a spirit of its own as the authors become the Lady of Affalon and Eosaidh as the dark swirling currents of the marshland forever swirl about them and the reader. The book speaks directly to the soul and takes the reader to a reality that is timeless, a reality that is Earth born. Its the most awe inspiring work i have ever read and has left me emotionally drained. It has the truth of the Land as a living being deeply embedded in it. It speaks of love that spans the aeons and the devastation that can follow if that love is not allowed to flourish. It is a love between souls and the love that must exist between us and the Land in order for us to be true to ourselves and each other. The book is written in such a way that you cannot help but become one or the other(Eosaidh or Vivian)in the reading of it, so what it must have been like for the writers to bring this telling to birth is unimaginable.
The Land shows us the disharmony that can result when the Lands own story and truth is ignored and our own predilections are projected on to Her, or worse, away from Her. If you are at all moved to walk the way of and listen to our Ancestors, the spirits of Affalon, the Land of Britain, The Lady then this beautiful book will inspire you and tear you apart at the same time. If I could give it more than five stars I would. It really is that good.